Skip to content

Cooking a Cowboy Steak

  • cowboy steak(s) –> aka a bone-in ribeye
  • olive oil
  • your favorite steak seasoning (we used “Spicewalla’s” Cowboy Steak Rub)
  • optional: homemade or store-bought compound butter
add main protein to cart
Prep time
5 minutes
Cook time
30-40 minutes
2 people per cowboy steak

We recommend the reverse sear method for a thick cut steak like this one:

-Rub the steak down with a little olive oil and season generously with your favorite seasoning. Here we used “Spicewalla” Cowboy Steak rub.

-Place in the oven at 250-275° on a wire rack. Monitor the temperature until it reaches about 115° internal.

-Remove the steak from the oven and sear both sides in a pan on high heat for about 2 minutes per side, or until the internal temperature reaches between 125-130° for medium rare.

-Allow the steak to rest for 10 minutes, slice, and enjoy! –> This steak was topped with a simple garlic, parsley compound butter.

Share recipe
You might also like
Cooking video and recipe for Filet Mignon with Mushroom Sauce
Filet Mignon Dinner

This easy and delicious Prime Filet Mignon recipe will deliver a steakhouse quality meal right at home!

See Recipe
25 minute air fryer chicken wings coated in SoLa Cajun Seasoning and Soskin's Buffalo Hot Sauce
Air Fryer Chicken Wings

25 minute air fryer chicken wings for game day! Find all the seasonings and sauces at APM!

See Recipe
Salmon Salad made by Merrick's Meat, using fresh Faroe Island Salmon, avocado, cucumber, kimchi, and Yuzu Jalapeño Dressing
Salmon Salad

Keep your New Year’s diet going strong by fueling your body with this fresh Faroe Island Salmon Salad!

See Recipe